Wednesday, 16 March 2011

The Amanda Knox Appeal - Is the Second Time the Charm?




The murder of Meredith Kercher has been publicized around the world. The Italian and British media have been closely following the story since 2007, keeping the public anxiously awaiting for justice to be served.

The American media is now jumping on board and letting the American people know what is happening to one of their own, halfway across the world. Is Amanda Knox guilty of murder? Did she put a knife to her flatmates throat and end her life? Or is a serious injustice being done to an American citizen, a young woman who simply wanted to expand her horizons and spend a year studying in Italy? Here we examine the Amanda Knox Appeal..

The Timeline..

There was a great deal of evidence that led to Knox’s conviction on December 4, 2009. The main things that convinced the jury that she was guilty were the bloody footprints found under Kercher’s body, Knox’s dishonest and changing stories, and her DNA found on the murder weapon and around the flat. However, Knox maintains her innocence. Her lawyers began the appeals process in April of 2010. She was then granted a trial de novo, which began December 11.

A week later, the court agreed to review the DNA evidence that was used to convict Knox. As of February 9th, forensic experts were given 90 days to review important evidence. They must be finished their research by May 9th, and their conclusion must be presented to the court by the 21st.

The new DNA findings will be presented in front of a new jury, and just as importantly, in front of a new judge. The judge assigned to the trial is known both for his fairness and his open-mindedness, which Knox and her team find encouraging. Whether this will make a difference in Knox’s conviction is yet to be seen.

Does Amanda Have a Case?

The most important evidence against Amanda Knox was her changing story, her bloody footprint, and the DNA found on what is said to be the murder weapon. However, there are problems with all of this evidence.

Knox first accused a local bar owner, named Patrick Lumumba, of killing Meredith. Lumumba was later exonerated and Knox was made out to look like a malicious liar. Yes, accusing an innocent man of murder is malicious. However, in the same position, its likely that many terrified young women would also lie to save themselves.

The way the police questioned Knox may have also caused her to so frequently change stories. Knox claimed that she had been mistreated by police, questioned for almost 53 consecutive hours, and was hit when she couldn’t remember the answer to a question. The police deny this and have also charged her with slander. Yet, it is impossible to know exactly went on during questioning.

Another important thing to consider is that the DNA evidence used in the trial may have been contaminated. There was a delay of 49 days from when police arrived on the murder scene to when DNA samples were collected. Prosecutors argue that if DNA evidence had been disturbed during this period it would have worked out in Knox’s favor, but no one can be sure until the evidence is reexamined.

Even the bloody footprint, found under Meredith Kercher’s body, is up for debate. The footprint was automatically linked to Knox, but was never verified to be hers. The footprint did belong to a woman, but could have been anyone’s, since investigators were unable to match it to any of Knox’s shoes. This leaves many people questioning the validity of much of the evidence.

Possible Outcomes of the Amanda Knox Appeal

Statistically speaking, in the Italian court system, around half of all appealed convictions result in a different sentence. Many defendants are given entirely different convictions, while others receive reduced sentences.

Rudy Guede, who was also convicted of the murder and sexual assault of Meredith Kercher, was able to appeal and reduce his sentence. His first trial resulted in a 30-year sentence, but after he appealed the conviction, he was given a much lesser sentence of 16 years.

If Amanda Knox’s appeal goes similarly, she may be looking at a sentence of around 13 years for her part in the crime. Unfortunately, if she is again found guilty, she may be looking at an even harsher punishment. Prosecutors are pushing the judge to lengthen her sentence to a life term.

Amanda Knox has been quoted as saying, “I want justice for Meredith, but this injustice to me is unacceptable. I am also asking for justice.” Knox’s family, friends, and others who believe in her innocence are positive that the trial de novo will bring her the justice she deserves. For the rest of the world, we will just have to wait and see what the Amanda Knox appeal will bring.

» Next article: Ghadaffi's Female Nurse.
« Previous article: The Amanda Knox Biography

2 comments:

alexpmgr8 said...

Awfull, I hope the italians redeem themselves. Unreal !!! Terrrible for the Kerchers.

Free RS & AK

RIP Meredith uk, alex

thanh nguyen said...

lực cũng không có cách nào phá đâu.

- Lão Đại, vậy triệu tập bộ đội của chúng ta trên đại lục tới đây. Họ có
số lượng, chúng ta bộ không có sao? - Tiểu Phi Hiệp đề nghị.

Nghe thế, Đoạn Vân nhìn về phía Pháp Lạp Kì, nói:

- Pháp Lạp Kì, bây giờ có bao nhiêu Cuồng chiến sĩ hậu giai?

- Đại khái có năm ngàn. Tuy không được phát thuốc nhưng trải qua thời
gian lâu như vậy, bọn họ cũng đã trải qua nhiều cuộc khảo nghiệm sinh tử
ở ma quỷ thức huấn luyện rồi, nhờ đó họ có tiến bộ rất nhanh. - Pháp Lạp
Kì trả lời.

- Lão Đại, hà tất chi mà phải phái ra Cuồng chiến sĩ? Phì Tử sư đoàn vốn
ngưỡng mộ ta phi thường, còn lấy tên ta làm phiên hào, bọn họ cũng có
chiến lực rất tốt. Một vạn hùng tộc Thú Nhân, thực lực trung bình trong
khoảng thần cấp. Hơn nữa, hùng tộc Thú Nhân không kiêng kị gì nước cả.

Phì Tử lúc này tiến cử Phì Tử hùng tộc sư đoàn của hắn. Tướng sĩ sư đoàn
đó, toàn bộ đều là hùng tộc Thú Nhân, hơn nữa là Phì Tử tự mình thu phục
những bộ lạc hùng tộc mà thành lập nên.
dịch vụ hoàn thuế gtgt
dịch vụ kế toán thuế trọn gói
dịch vụ quyết toán thuế
khoá học kế toán thuế
trung tâm kế toán
dịch vụ báo cáo thuế

dich vu ke toan noi bo
dịch vụ dọn dẹp sổ sách trọn gói
kế toán cho giám đốc
học kế toán thực hành
tiếng anh cho người đi làm
khoá học kế toán excel
forum rao vat
mu private

trung tâm kế toán tại tphcm
dịch vụ kế toán trọn gói

- Giai vị của họ quá thấp, cho dù biết thủy tính, chống lại với đám Bạch
hùng đó thì có khác gì trứng chọi đá. - Đoạn Vân phản đối.

Ngẫm nghĩ một lát, Đoạn Vân ra lệnh: